DJI Phantom 4 Collides with Black Hawk Helicopter

2
605
Inflight collision of UAS and helicopter- figure 1

The National Transportation Safety Board determined Thursday the operator of a drone that collided with an U.S. Army helicopter failed to see and avoid the helicopter because he was intentionally flying the drone out of visual range and did not have adequate knowledge of regulations and safe operating practices.

This Christmas, we expect a record-number of drones sales and more drone accidents from unlicensed, unknowing pilots. A cohesive and easily accessible governance framework is needed to bridge the drone knowledge gap and prevent accidents like these from happening.

Background:

This event took place September 21, 2017 when a DJI Phantom 4 collided with the UH-60 Blackhawk helicopter. The Chinese manufactured aircraft, representative of nearly 70% of all drones, travelled 2.5 miles away from the pilot and during twilight hours – both violations of federal regulation, and though the collision occurred under the permitted 400 FT AGL, the pilot had earlier flown well above the legal limit. The NTSB determined that the pilots were at fault, not the technology; identifying the direct causes as a failure to “monitor other aircraft” and a failure in “the use of policy/procedure.” Causal factors leading to these failures were “a lack of knowledge of procedures… and regulatory requirements.”

The incident took place near Hoffman Island, New York. The helicopter landed safely; the drone was destroyed. A 1 1/2 – inch dent was found on the leading edge of one of the helicopter’s four main rotor blades and parts of the drone were found lodged in the helicopter’s engine oil cooler fan.

The drone operator was unaware of the collision until an NTSB investigator contacted him. The operator was also not aware of temporary flight restrictions that were in place at the time because of presidential travel and a United Nations General Assembly session. He was flying recreationally and did not hold an FAA remote pilot certificate.

The full investigative report is available online at https://go.usa.gov/xnnkh

2 COMMENTS

  1. Oh dear! – this just highlights how safe we need to be when operating drones, this is one reckless user! Gives us all a bad name, I hope cases like this don’t continue otherwise more strict measures will arise or total bans! Unfortunate occurrence, but an interesting read. Thanks guys

  2. this incident need to be analysed .

    If drone have Collision sensor ( just like an automobile reverse sensor or otherwise ) , to safely identify any flying object closing down to drone in 5 – 10 meter range .
    probably if it had, an alarm would be sent to the drone operator and drone itself would then take an auto-corrective flight plan to avoid collision.

    ( just a thought ).. happy safe journeys ahead.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here